|
A Philadelphia Region Organization
Development Network Special Event
May
18-19, 2000
McCall
Field
Upper Darby, Pennsylvania
"Organizations are like organisms.
They constantly adapt to change and new challenges, striving to
ensure that needs are recognized and met. They work to stay in harmony
and balance, and to keep important inter-relationships functioning
smoothly, leading to the ultimate goal of survival and growth. "
Or ...
An organization is a machine that occasionally
breaks down, and requires the services of an external expert to
fix it. When that happens, it needs to be re-tooled or leveraged
to become more efficient and may even require periodic re-engineering
in order to remain "cutting edge".
The metaphors we use reflect the way
we experience and understand our worlds and in fluence how we engage
and are engaged. On May 18-19th, the last PRODN special event of
the 1999 - 2000 season sponsored Bob Marshak, internationally recognized
for his work with metaphors and organization change. We spent two
days with Bob Marshak exploring how language illuminates the way
we make meaning for ourselves and the organizations we live in.
Bob provided us with models that "framed our thinking".
We also spent time in conversations exploring how our own words
provided doorways into our unconscious
During the introduction one participant
imagined that the two days we would spend together would be like
the "Wizard of Oz". Bob smiled and said, "I'm just
the Wizard, you will pull back the curtain and find that each of
you have within yourselves the skill you seek." And with that
the sky darkened, the wind picked up, the rain fell and we were
off on our own journey of discovery (literally and figuratively!).
"By changing the controlling rhetoric,
metaphors and images, you can change reality" - Bob Marshak
Bob, in his article "Managing the
Metaphors of Change", Organizational Dynamics, 22 (1), 44-
56 1993 identifies four types and metaphors of change. (Figure 1)
|
Figure
1
Types and Metaphors of Change
|
Fix
&
Repair |
Maintain |
- Repair
Person
- Mechanic
- Maintenance
Worker
|
- Tool
Kit
- Fix
What’s Broken
- Restore
- Avoid
Down Time
|
|
Build
&
Develop
|
Develop |
|
- Development
Plans
- Build
Foundation
- Enhance/Increase
- Targets
& Goals
|
|
Move
&
Relocate
|
Transition |
|
- Maps
& Timetables
- Right
Path
- Avoid
Obstacles
- Destination
|
|
Liberate
&
Recreate
|
Transform |
- Liberator
- Visionary
- Creator
|
- Get
Out of the Box
- Awaken
or Inspire
- New
Possibilities
- Renew,
Reinvent, Re-engineer
|
© 2000
by Robert J. Marshak, Ph.D.
|
In the session, we real organizational
change issues in terms of each of the four types of change. We learned
through this activity how to identify how we were framing the kind
of change we were facing through the language we used in our descriptions.
We came to understand how metaphors are
used both consciously and unconsciously. Leveraging language for
organizational change would require us to listen on multiple levels.
(Figure 2)
|
Figure
2
Leveraging Language for Change
Types of
metaphors to listen for:
- Metaphors
that are consciously created analogies or comparisons.
For example: "This organization is a pressure cooker."
• Use to assess what is
• Use to imagine what could be
- Metaphors
that are unconscious cognitive patterns that structure/describe
experience. These may be expressed or revealed as:
• Metaphorical images or symbols
that emerge in discussions, but are not explicitly created
for purposes of analogy or comparison. For example: "Everyone
was dancing around the real issues in the meeting."
• Underlying image schematics
or metaphors that shape or inform descriptions/discussions.
For example: "I had to get over a few rough
spots and get back on track before I was able to
move forward in my life." (Life is a Journey)
© 2000 by
Robert J. Marshak, Ph.D. |
Bob offered some tips for working with
metaphors:
- Listen for metaphors and images, explicit
and underlying organizing themes.
- Listen for the meaning made by the
person using the metaphor not for the meaning you would attribute
to the metaphor. One person's pelting downpour may be another
person's nourishing rain.
- Try getting in "sync" with
the metaphor and meaning. Actively listen to draw out their meaning
and imagery
- Inquire about the unspoken or neglected
aspects of their metaphor based on your understanding of the situation.
- Suggest ways to rethink the metaphor
by repudiating, re-framing and replacing it.
- Remember the most powerful aspects
of the metaphor may be unconscious or out-of-awareness. Don't
force insights. Invite curiosity and speculation.
By the end of our time together, each
person in the room recognized the power of metaphor. We spent time
near the end of the session talking about the ethics of what we
had learned. This work requires clarity about contract and purposes,
dynamics and issues of the situation, and must always be in service
of client needs and objectives.
We left on cloud nine!!
--Ilene Wasserman and Nancy
Roggen
Robert J. Marshak, PHD, is an internationally
renowned organizational development consultant known for his pioneering
work on the use of metaphors and symbolic data in organizational diagnosis
and change. His article, The Tao of Change, which compares North American
and East Asian culturally based models of change, is considered one
of the classics of organization development. He is on the editorial
board of the upcoming special issue of the Journal of Applied Behavioral
Sciences, devoted to the use of metaphors in organizational consulting.
Dr. Marshak has over twenty-five years
experience working with corporations, associations, and government
agencies to:
- Create future direction and purpose
through strategic planning, organizational assessment, and/or
new mission development
- Reorganize or design new organizational
structures and systems to meet changing opportunities and challenges
- Build teamwork, partnerships and alliances
within and across organizational components,
- Address globalization issues, including
strategic, structural andmulti -cultural dimensions
Dr. Marshak also maintains part-time
affiliations with universities and institutes in the United States,
United Kingdom, and Republic of Korea where he leads seminars and
workshops on organizational consulting and change.
|